Crossover Records

crossover_blue_suede.jpg (12234 bytes)

Crossover: The same record appearing on multiple music charts. Example: "Blue Suede Shoes" by Carl Perkins was listed on the Country, Pop and R&B charts.

Volume of Crossovers, 1950-1958
Percentage of all records on the pop, country & western, and rhythm & blues charts that crossed boundaries

    Pop Records
  Country and Western Records
  Rhythm and Blues Records


Percentage

Base number of records

Percentage

Base number of records

Percentage

Base number of records
1950 16 (168) 43 (49) 15 (67)
1951 11 (167) 20 (46) 17 (66)
1952 8 (144) 24 (41) 3 (65)
1953 17 ((94) 23 (48) 11 (57)
1954 15 (136) 21 (56) 25 (57)
1955 9 (276) 3 (65) 29 ((80)
1956 14 (499) 33 ((46) 76 (82)
1957 23 (483) 64 (59) 87 (99)
1958 35 (500) 53 ((107) 94 (155)

Source, Billboard music popularity charts, Best-Selling Singles. The numbers listed alongside the percentages are the total number of records on the chart for the year.

The first records to crossover were by black vocals groups and signaled the beginning of the rock era.

The first groups consisted of members who generally were 20 -30 years old. The records were rooted in jazz and R&B and adult oriented. The Dominoes and the Midnighters would be examples of this group.

200px-Federa2.jpg (8853 bytes)

"Sixty Minute Man"  recorded in 1951 by the Dominoes (#1 R&B, 17 pop) was the first significant R&B record to crossover to the Pop chart. The significance being that it was recorded by a small independent (Federal), its ranking on the pop chart and  large sales to teenagers, many who were white. The song represented all the reasons ( heavy beat, suggestive lyrics and singing) that parents didn't want their children listening to rhythm and blues.

"I was being lambasted for dirty lyrics for dirty lyrics on "Sixty Minute Man".The problem was that white kids were listening to those things for the first time.It was alright so long as blacks were listening, but as soon as whites started listening,it was no good. Then it became a big political thing."
Ralph Bass, producer Federal Records

"Sixty Minute Man" would be considered a fluke and soon forgotten.

"Crying in the Chapel" recorded in 1953 by the Orioles was another important record. The Orioles in contrast to The Ink Spots and The Mills Brothers sounded unmistakably black. An old country ballad, "Crying in the Chapel"  (#11) almost made it to the fable top ten and showed that there was a white audience for rhythm and blues records.

1954's "Work With Me Annie" by the Midnighters caused another uproar. The lyric "Can I get some work tonight, baby? had an unambiguous meaning and "Annie, please don't cheat/Give me all my meat" was thrown in for who weren't sure what the lyrics song was about.

"Work With Me Annie" was  recorded  on Syd Nathan's Federal label and Nathan took full advantaged of a joke by a west coast deejay. It seems that the deejay had told his listeners if they liked "Work With Me Annie" they'd love the squeal "Annie Had A Baby." When orders began coming in for the nonexistent record Nathan wrote, recorded and released a record by that name in 1954.

The teenagers loved it. For those who weren't sure of what the lyrics meant the Midnighter's follow up record was "Annie Had A Baby (Can't Work No More).

"Work With Me Annie" led to a number of songs such as "Annie's Aunt Fannie," "Henry's Got Flat Feet (Can't Dance No More)," and Etta James' "answer" song "Roll With Me Henry" renamed "The Wallflower". Georgia Gibbs would cover "The Wallflower," renamed "Dance With Me Henry," clean up the lyrics and make it a #1 pop hit.

1954: The Year of Crossover

In 1954, rhythm and blues began a transition to the younger sound that would be called doo wop to distinguish it from the earlier sound. As black vocal groups became more successful in crossing over as the songs became more melodic with younger lyrics and universal themes that appealed to the younger audience and was perceived as less threatening by their parents. The crossover floodgates opened wide in 1954.

"Anyone who says rock and roll is a passing fad or a flash- in-the-pan trend along the music road has rocks in the head, dad!" 
Alan Freed

The Major record companies had always considered rock and roll a fad. The success of the crossovers was forcing them to finally face reality. The industry's response would be one of "covering."

R&B songs that crossed over to the 1955 Pop Charts

 

Song

Artist

Record Label

First Appearance

Peak Chart Position

Tweedle Dee
Tutti Fuitti
Ko Ko Mo
Pledging My Love
Dance With Me Henry
My Babe
Most of All
Don't Be Angry
Rock Around the Clock
Seventeen
Ain't That a Shame
Love, Love, Love
Maybellene
Only You (And You Alone)
At My Front Door
Come Home
When You Dance
My Boy -- Flat Top
Why Don't You Write (To) Me
Burn That Candle
Dim, Dim the Lights
Smoky Joe's Cafe
Earth Angel
The Great Pretender
White Christmas
LaVern Baker
Little Richard
Gene & Eunice
Johnny Ace
Etta James
Little Walter
Moonglows
Nappy Brown
Bill Haley and His Comets
Boyd Bennett & His Rockers
Fats Domino
Clovers
Chuck Berry
Platters
El Dorados
Bubber Johnson
Turbans
Boyd Bennett & His Rockers
Jacks
Bill Haley and His Comets
Bill Haley
Robins
Penguins
Platters
Drifters
Atlantic
Specialty
Combo, Atlantic
Duke
Modern
Checker
Chess
Savoy
Decca
King
Imperial
Atlantic
Chess
Mercury
Vee-Jay
King
Herald
King
RPM
Decca
Decca
Atco
Dootone
Mercury
Atlantic
January 15, 1955
January 28, 1955
January 29, 1955
February 19. 1955
February 19, 1955
Unknown
April 9, 1955
April 30, 1955
May 14, 1955
July 9. 1955
July 16, 1955
July 20, 1955
August 20, 1955
October 11, 1955
October 15, 1955
November 12, 1955
November 12, 1955
November 12, 1955
November 12, 1955
November 19, 1955
November 20, 1955
December 10, 1955
December 21, 1954
December 24, 1955
December 31, 1955
14
17
6
1
17
106
5
25
5
10
5
10
30
5
5
17
92
33
31
9
82
11
79
8
1
80